‘If you haven’t served, respect those who have’: Nato soldiers on Trump’s slurs
It was shortly before dawn and Bruce Moncur was eating breakfast when the American warplane roared overhead. The 22-year-old reservist had been stationed in Afghanistan for three weeks when the A-10 Warthog strafed the camp west of Kandahar City where and he and 30 other Canadian soldiers had spent the night. Moncur was struck by shrapnel and thrown to the ground. When he regained consciousness, he was bleeding from a large head wound, and believed he would die. The friendly fire attack killed one Canadian solider and left five others gravely wounded. Now an elementary school teacher, Moncur had nearly 5% of his brain removed, and had to relearn how to walk, talk, read and write. Donald Trump provoked a storm of diplomatic fury with his claims that Nato allies had “stayed a little off the frontlines” in Afghanistan. The comments were condemned as “insulting and frankly appalling” by the UK prime minister, Keir Starmer, who joined other leaders in expressing disgust and anger at the president. On Saturday, in a rare partial climbdown, Trump praised UK troops as being “among the greatest of all warriors”. His post on Truth Social, acknowledging that 457 UK troops had died in Afghanistan, is reported to have come after King Charles expressed his concerns, through private channels, about Trump’s earlier slur on UK forces. But Trump’s post did not apologise for his earlier comments. Crucially, nor did he clarify or withdraw his denigration of the role played by troops of other Nato allies. And for the men and women who fought alongside US troops in Afghanistan and Iraq, the damage already done by Trump’s earlier comment cut especially deep. “Our friends needed help and I and so many others answered that call. Now, my sacrifices are now being thrown in my face as ‘not enough’,” said Moncur, who accused the US president of “deep disrespect” towards veterans. “Nobody named Trump was on the frontline with me. And his sons were nowhere to be seen in the Afghan desert,” he said. Trump had fired his opening salvo as he headed to the World Economic Forum in Davos, telling reporters: “I know we’ll come to [Nato’s] rescue, but I just really do question whether or not they’ll come to ours.” Later that day, he told Fox News that he was “not sure” Nato would meet the “ultimate test” of defending the US if it were under threat. “We’ve never needed them … They’ll say they sent some troops to Afghanistan … and they did, they stayed a little back – a little off the frontlines,” he said. He added the US had been “very good to Europe and to many other countries. It has to be a two-way street.” The only time Nato has ever invoked its mutual defence clause – stating that an attack on one member represents an attack on all – came after the terrorist attacks of 9/11, when member states deployed thousands of troops to Afghanistan. In the 20-year conflict that followed, 3,486 Nato troops died, of which the majority, 2,461, were US service members. But at times during the war, allies experienced a death rate higher than their American counterparts. In 2006, Canadian troops were moved from the relative safety of Kabul to the frontlines of the deadly Kandahar region as part of Operation Medusa, in part to relieve American troops. The vast majority of Canada’s 159 combat deaths happened during the operation. After comrades were killed, their remains were placed in a flag-draped casket and brought to a plane, giving soldiers one last chance to bid farewell. “All countries saluted,” Moncur said. “We showed our respect – as one.” Trump, who avoided the Vietnam-era military draft five times, has a long history of disparaging and belittling the military. Paweł “Naval” Mateńczuk, a Polish special forces veteran, said that in general, soldiers “try to stay pretty numb” to what politicians say. “But today is the anniversary of my friend’s death in Afghanistan and it’s hard to just look past that,” he said. Over 19 years, Poland – which had joined Nato only two years before, in 2001 – sent more than 33,000 troops and military personnel to Afghanistan and 44 were killed in the line of duty. Mateńczuk, who was deployed to Afghanistan with Poland’s elite special forces unit GROM on four assignments, said that while president Trump was “often banging on about gratitude or someone thanking him for something”, veterans were not looking for that, because they “felt that gratitude first-hand, serving alongside American troops” and “you can’t break a bond like that easily”. “But what we carry with us as veterans is not just the gruelling experience of active combat, but the loss of our friends. Thousands more brought back memories that were far from pleasant. I know history can be shortsighted, but I never imagined it would be quite this shortsighted,” he said from Warsaw. “They were grateful we were there, taking part in an American war. It wasn’t a Polish war, or a European war; it was a war against global terrorism, and it was the US that had been attacked,” he said. On social media, the Polish prime minister, Donald Tusk, recalled a ceremony for the five fallen Polish soldiers in Ghazni, Afghanistan in 2011. “The American officers who accompanied me then told me that America would never forget the Polish heroes,” he wrote. “Perhaps they will remind President Trump of that fact.” A day after Trump questioned the value of Nato support for the US, the Polish defence minister published the full list of 44 Polish troops and military personnel killed in Afghanistan. Mateńczuk said Trump should consider apologising to the families of veterans, particularly those who had lost their lives. “There are so many Polish widows and orphaned children. If anyone is owed an apology, it’s them,” he said. In the United Kingdom, condemnation of the president’s comments has cut across the political spectrum, reflecting the reality that 457 British troops died, while another 2,000 military and civilian personnel were wounded in action. Richard Streatfield, a former army major in charge of 150 troops on the frontline in Sangin between 2009 and 2010, said Trump’s comments were “deeply insulting”. Streatfield, now a Liberal Democrat councillor in Kent, said he had overseen soldiers in “the most violent town” in Helmand, which in turn was “the most violent province” in all of Afghanistan. “We put in huge amounts of effort and some paid the ultimate sacrifice. Five of the company were killed and 50 were wounded. So to be told that your service was not as demanding or as difficult as the Americans’ is untrue, and deeply insulting,” he said. “In broad terms, the Americans, the Danes and us lost proportionally as many people as each other in relation to the size of force that we had in the country.” Streatfield said his American comrades would be “ashamed” of Trump’s remarks. “The American troops I served alongside … know precisely what kind of sacrifices were made by everybody there. Their own service and sacrifice is diminished by what Trump has said.” “The Americans needed us as allies. They are the ones who called in the article 5 requirement after 9/11. We heard the call, made the sacrifices, and to be told you’ve taken a step back is incredible.” Streatfield said many of his British comrades were also outraged by Trump’s remarks. “We are very passionate about the job that we did in Afghanistan, which was, to a large extent, undermined by Donald Trump’s own decisions. He’s the one who set the timetable for the Taliban to get back into power. He is the one that started the American withdrawal. Twenty million Afghan women and girls are now living in terrible conditions under the Taliban directly as a result of his decisions.” He added: “If you haven’t served, don’t do anything other than respect those people who have.” After his Fox News interview, Trump continued his campaign, posting on Truth Social: “Maybe we should have put Nato to the test: Invoked Article 5, and forced Nato to come here and protect our Southern Border from further Invasions of Illegal Immigrants, thus freeing up large numbers of Border Patrol Agents for other tasks.” Moncur said that for someone who has never experienced the harrowing realities of frontline combat, “the pain that he has caused, and is causing, is immeasurable and it is shameful. “To see how American treat their friends now – who needs enemies?”






